By: Craig Fehr, CFA, Investment Strategist
& Angelo Kourkafas, CFA, Associate Analyst
- Stocks pull back – Canadian and U.S. stocks continued trading lower Thursday (Dec. 6), with the TSX declining more than 2%, the S&P 500 falling 2.5% and the Dow dropping nearly 700 points. Stocks gave back last week's solid gains, turning negative on the year as the shine on last weekend's tariff truce faded and worries over the outlook for slower economic growth returned.
- Trade optimism fades - Global stock markets rallied on Monday (Dec. 3) as fears of an escalating trade war between the U.S. and China eased on news that an agreement at last weekend's G20 meeting produced a temporary halt to retaliatory tariffs between the world's two largest economies. That optimism waned on Tuesday, which we'd attribute to the realization that the temporary agreement (90 days) is no guarantee of a lasting trade resolution. It's encouraging to see both sides are signaling a willingness to come to the table, but we expect U.S.-China trade concerns to remain a source of market volatility heading into 2019. Signs of progress between now and March would likely be well-received by the markets, but Tuesday's selloff suggests investors are skeptical a binding agreement will be reached in the next few months.
- Flattening yield curve back in the spotlight – Market anxiety was further heightened by renewed flattening in the yield curve. In particular, two-year U.S. interest rates are now above five-year rates, reigniting fears of an inverted yield curve and the belief that this may signal an economic downturn ahead. In similar fashion, Canadian two-year rates are nearly level with five-year rates, the narrowest spread since 2007. We'd note the following:
- The 2- to 5-year segment of the yield curve is a rather narrow slice of the rate spectrum and does not fully represent an inversion of the yield curve. For perspective, an inverted yield curve (when short interest rates are higher than long rates) does have a track record of signaling economic weakness, since it indicates an environment in which higher short-term rates reflect tightening monetary (Federal Reserve and Bank of Canada) policy and lower longer-term rates signal potentially weaker expectations for inflation and growth.
- We agree that a fully inverted yield curve is a cautious signal, but historically a more reliable measure is 3-month rates compared to 10-year rates. This measure of the yield curve is flatter, but still positively sloped rather than inverted. We think this is consistent with our view that we are in the latter stages of the cycle, but a recession is not imminent.
- This is not new. We have seen the market panic over the flatter yield curve several times in the past few years. Traditionally, a flattening yield curve is a sign of a maturing economic cycle, not the end of it. In fact, in the past, even when the yield curve has inverted, a recession did not emerge for an extended period of time. We don't dismiss the risks that are prevalent in today's investment environment, but we think the risk of a recession in 2019 is quite low. We expect the result will likely be ongoing volatility, not the imminent end of this bull market.
- Positive fundamentals haven't changed overnight - This bull market is mature, in our view, but not out of gas. The flattening yield curve reflects the changing complexion of the investment backdrop, in which central bank stimulus is fading and economic growth is likely to tick down a bit next year. That said, the fundamental backdrop remains solid. Following a year of roughly 3% GDP growth in the U.S. and 2% growth in Canada, the pace of growth in 2019 is likely to slow modestly but remain positive. Unemployment rates are at cyclically- and historically-low levels and wage growth is firming, two key pillars of support for the consumer and thus the economy. In addition, corporate profit growth – while not likely to match this year's very strong 20% pace – should remain healthy next year. The combination of positive GDP and earnings growth has traditionally been a sound foundation for market performance over time. While fluctuating trade views and a kink in the yield curve represent short-term catalysts for volatility, the S&P 500 is still up from the October lows and less than 8% from the all-time high. A wider lens shows that the S&P 500 has returned more than 24% over the past two years, despite enduring two separate 10% corrections in 2018. Near-term jitters could make for a bumpy ride as we close out 2018, but looking ahead, we don't expect them to outweigh the still-positive fundamental backdrop.